  Judas Priest
   Rising in the East DVD
   Review by Gary Hill
  
 Well,            what a time it is to be a Judas Priest fan. Over the course of the last            couple years we got the news that Rob Halford (the metal god) had returned            to the fold, then we got the reunion showing at Ozzfest followed by            the awesome Angel of Retribution album and two legs of a tour (at least            here in the US) and now this DVD! It's hard to imagine much more on            the wish list of Priest fans. Frankly, I've felt that all of the above            were at least very close to, if not a bit above the level of anything            else the band have done in their career. It's as if the reunion has            brought a new vitality and fire to these guys - and in fact, that's            probably the case. This DVD certainly shows a band that has never been            better in so many ways. Yes, some of the material sounds different than            it did on the studio releases, but I've always felt that bands that            came out and delivered "note for note" copies of their albums            were just about phoning in their performances because live shows should            be more than what the CD is. Most of the material here is, in fact stronger            than the original versions, and in many cases these are the best live            recordings available. So, overall, this is a stellar live DVD from a            band who is performing beyond expectations. 
Now let's            have a look at some of the details that make it so. First, let's have            a look at the set list - mind you this one is a bit of a mixed bag,            but more positive than negative. They include a lot of Priest classics            that are pretty much "required" of the band. But there are            some surprises, too. For one thing, this set includes new live recordings            of "The Ripper," and "Hell Bent For Leather," both            of which we didn't get on our tour here in the States - well at least            the headlining tour. There are also five (that's half the album) tracks            off Angel of Retribution. That alone would make this video a "must            have" for Priest fans. Everyone one of the songs is a smoker live,            too. Many songs, the aforementioned AOR cuts, "Victim of Changes,"            and "Painkiller" are the ones that jump out at me as I write            this - exceed both the studio versions, and in the cases of those last            two, any live version I've ever heard. I suppose it's unrealistic to            assume that such cuts as "Breaking The Law," and "Living            After Midnight" could have been bypassed in favor of some less            overplayed numbers. Still, while "Turbo Lover" and "I'm            A Rocker" are definitely far better here than on their studio releases,            I could have stood to see those left out in favor of something less            well represented over the years. That said, the cool acoustic version            of "Diamonds and Rust" is a nice touch. In other words, while            there might be some points where I could see the set being changed for            the better, this is a darned good set under any interpretation. Besides,            I don't think any band can do a show that is exactly the songs that            each fan wants to hear - unless they play every song they've ever done            - and again that's unrealistic. 
Looking            at the performances, in most cases these are the definitive versions            of these songs - at least in my opinion. Now, that doesn't mean that            they are precisely the way they were played on the original album. Most            often they are better. There has been a lot of talk about Rob Halford            not making the high notes. This simply isn't true. He hits them when            he needs to, at least as well as he did in the heyday of the band. It            seems to me that he is showing a certain amount of restraint as he's            matured as a vocalist. I mean, it's kind of like the guitarist who when            he's young feels that he has to show with every riff just how fast and            furious he can play. But as he gains a level of maturity he realizes            that if he focuses on playing meaty solos, and only putting out the            speed when its really called for, that it adds to the music and makes            those burst all the more dramatic. I think that Halford has learned            the same thing over the years when it comes to his vocal performance            - and in terms of the overall show - it really does add a lot. Now,            that said, I also remember people saying that when they did "Exciter"            (still awesome that they pulled out this old chestnut) that they knocked            the song down a couple notches to allow Halford to sing it. Well, I            swear that when I saw them in Chicago, they played it in the same key            as the album, but on this DVD, it is stepped down. Still, it's killer            to hear that one in any form as it is definitely been under-represented            over the years in their set. I still think that, despite the fact that            I really always like Les Binks a lot, Scott Travis is the best drummer            the Priest have ever had, and he is on fire on this performance, as            he was on every show I've seen since the band reunited. Tipton and Downing            are playing together in ways that I don't think they've ever managed            before - and theirs is one of the defining twin guitar attacks in metal,            so that says a lot. Ian Hill, as always, is the understated, but very            dependable bass line to the band, and for once gets a bit of chance            to share the limelight more than he usual did in the past. The result            is a fine tuned, live metal machine that is firing on all thrusters            throughout. 
Well,            that brings us to the actual film itself. I'd have to say that the sound            on this recording is impeccable. The filmography is definitely unobtrusive            and on the money. There are moments where the lighting doesn't seem            perfect, but having shot the band, I can tell you that even still photography            under the varying lights is tough - I can't begin to imagine trying            to do video. I guess the only real downside to this set is that there            aren't any bonus features. Still, as good as this DVD is, I can live            without it. For fans of the Priest, this one is a mandatory purchase.            If you've never seen the band live and would like to know what you're            missing you should always pick it up. In fact, there aren't all that            many metal concert videos that are on a even plane with this one - so            if you like those type of DVD's you should definitely get this one,            too. After the last couple years, these guys are going to have a hard            time competing with what they've done. I'm anxious to see what they            do. 
This review is  available in book format (hardcover and paperback)   in                     Music Street  Journal: 2006 Volume 1 at lulu.com/strangesound. 
	 |